Healthcare marketing just got more complicated.
You’re still fighting for map pack rankings and “near me” searches. But now there’s a second layer: AI-generated answers that are deciding which providers get mentioned before anyone even clicks a link.
The problem? Every agency’s suddenly an “AI visibility” expert. And in healthcare—where one screw-up can mean real liability—it’s tough to tell who actually knows what they’re doing versus who just added some slides to their deck.
If you’re trying to figure out which agencies can handle both SEO and this new GEO thing in the age of AI, here’s what matters.
Why Healthcare Makes This Harder
Healthcare isn’t like selling SaaS or running an e-commerce site. Mess up here and you’re not just burning your budget—you’re creating actual risk.
A real healthcare agency should be able to explain—without being weird about it—how they handle HIPAA-compliant analytics, review collection that won’t turn into compliance nightmares, medical content workflows with proper review processes, and claims language that stays within legal boundaries. If they’re selling you on volume (“we’ll crank out 200 optimized articles a month”), run. That’s a content factory, not someone who gets healthcare.
The better agencies spend weeks just mapping compliance requirements and review workflows before writing a single piece of content. That’s the kind of discipline that separates serious operators from content mills.
Force Them to Define “AI Visibility” With Real Numbers
AI visibility sounds impressive. The question is whether they can explain what they’re actually measuring.
A real answer includes specifics: tracking whether your practice shows up when people ask AI tools about conditions or treatments in your area, monitoring how often you get cited compared to competitors, measuring your share of mentions for key service lines, and ensuring AI systems can read and use your content accurately.
If they’re vague about measurement or can’t connect it to more patients walking through your door, it’s just buzzwords.
A recent Inc. article stated that Google’s AI summaries now reach over 2 billion users monthly, and traditional clicks are down 30% year over year. That’s a real shift. But only if the agency knows what to do about it.
Look for agencies that track “AI mention share”—for your priority searches, what percentage of AI-generated answers include your brand versus competitors.
Local Still Drives Most of Your Business
Most healthcare decisions start local: “dermatologist near me,” “walk-in clinic open Sunday,” “best ACL surgeon in Phoenix.”
That means your agency better be good at the boring stuff. Managing Google Business Profiles when you’ve got dozens of locations, keeping listings clean with no duplicates when doctors move between offices, building location pages that aren’t just the same template with different city names, and making sure local pages actually convert with clear calls to action for appointments and directions.
Truth is, lots of agencies can talk about AI. Way fewer can dominate local search for 40 locations while keeping everything accurate and compliant.
Even for digital-first healthcare companies that operate nationally, local intent matters. Agencies need to build visibility for location-specific healthcare searches while maintaining compliance across different state regulations. The best results come from patients actively searching for healthcare solutions in their area—not from interruptive advertising.
Systems Beat One-Off Content
In healthcare, content expires. Guidelines get updated. Treatments change. Doctors leave or join your practice. And AI? It repeats whatever’s most current and clear.
So stop asking “How much content will you make?” Instead, ask how they figure out what you should be writing about in the first place, what happens when medical information changes and how they catch and update it, who reviews content to make sure it’s medically accurate, and how they build service-line authority without cannibalizing pages.
You need an agency that sets up a real system—medical review, updating processes, version control. Not someone who floods your site with articles and crosses their fingers.
The better agencies use content governance frameworks where every piece gets tagged with a review date based on how quickly that medical information typically changes. Oncology content might be reviewed quarterly. Basic preventive care annually. They maintain rosters of medical reviewers who can sign off on updates within 48 hours when guidelines change. When the ADA updates diabetes guidelines, for example, the right agency has a system in place to update all affected content within days, not months—and that responsiveness often leads to rankings boosts because you’re among the first sources with current information.
The Technical Stuff Actually Matters
Good healthcare agenciesknow AI visibility isn’t about keywords. It’s about structure.
Can AI systems actually understand your content? Is the information organized in a way that makes it easy to extract and use? Structured content is 40% more likely to get cited. That means proper markup for your locations, doctors, and services. Clean site architecture. Content that makes sense even when AI pulls out just one section.
They should also understand E-E-A-T—Google’s framework for evaluating expertise and trustworthiness. In healthcare, this means doctor bios with real credentials, clear review processes, and transparent sourcing. This stuff matters for both search engines and AI systems.
Building authoritative signals takes time and consistency. Agencies working in the space typically plan for strategic media placements over 24-36 months, not quick wins. That’s not just link building—it’s establishing the kind of credibility that both search engines and AI systems use to determine whether a healthcare brand is trustworthy enough to reference.
AI Doesn’t Replace SEO—It Adds to It
The best agencies don’t make you choose between AI visibility and traditional SEO. They do both, and they should be able to explain how these pieces fit together naturally.
AI citations build awareness that eventually leads to people searching for your brand directly. Strong rankings and AI mentions feed off each other. Local SEO and AI visibility overlap, especially for location-based searches. And PR relationships help you build the authority that AI systems look for.
If they’re only hyped about AI and ignoring technical SEO or conversion optimization, they’re chasing the shiny new thing while forgetting what actually drives appointments.
There’s an interesting pattern emerging in healthcare: someone asks ChatGPT or Perplexity about symptoms or treatment options, sees a provider mentioned, doesn’t click through right away—but then three days later searches for that provider by name. The AI mention plants the seed. The direct search is where conversion happens.
This is why tracking “AI-to-brand-search attribution” matters—measuring the increase in branded searches after AI visibility improves.
Reports Should Tie to Real Results
New metrics only matter if they connect to your actual business.
Look for dashboards showing both traditional metrics (rankings, traffic, conversions) and new ones (AI mentions, citation frequency, how often you show up in AI answers). Monthly updates should explain what happened and why. And there should be a clear connection between visibility—whether from Google or ChatGPT—and actual patient bookings.
AI visibility is still pretty new. A decent agency will help you understand what the numbers mean for your goals. They won’t just dump a spreadsheet on you and call it a win.
The most important metric? How visibility translates to acquisition.
Healthcare organizations that were heavily dependent on paid advertising (with organic representing 5-10% of acquisition) can transform that to 25-30% of total customer acquisition. That’s the kind of shift that changes your unit economics and gives you more control over growth.
Red Flags
Watch out for agencies that promise huge results but can’t explain how they’ll actually do it, talk in circles when you ask what makes them different, or don’t have real healthcare clients beyond maybe one dentist. Be especially wary if they focus on cranking out massive amounts of content, can’t describe their medical review process, don’t ask about compliance requirements right away, or act like healthcare is just like any other industry.
Ask them directly: How do you measure this AI discovery stuff in healthcare specifically? How do you stay HIPAA-compliant with tracking and analytics? Walk me through your medical review process. Show me examples from other healthcare organizations like ours.
The agencies doing real work in this space should have documented case studies with actual healthcare companies, showing both the strategy and measurable business outcomes—not just traffic increases, but changes in how patients find and choose providers.
Pay Attention to What They Want to Do First
Good agencies start with the foundation, because that’s what lasts.
In healthcare, that means getting your technical setup and site structure right first, then building out your local presence with locations, providers, and specialties properly organized, establishing credibility through credentials, review processes, and appropriate citations, creating content organized around services and what patients are actually searching for, and finally building authority through PR and earned media.
If their pitch starts with vague ideas about “thought leadership” and “building backlinks” without first discussing structure and compliance, they’re winging it.
Agencies that understand healthcare know it takes time to build trust with both search engines and patients. Real transformation typically plays out over 24-36 months with consistent media placement and content development. That’s not a quick fix—it’s building a sustainable foundation that compounds over time.
A Word on Agencies Leading This Space
The market for AI visibility agencies is still emerging, but some patterns are worth noting.
Agencies that have positioned themselves explicitly around AI visibility and GEO—rather than just adding it to existing SEO services—tend to have more developed measurement frameworks and healthcare-specific compliance processes. They’re approaching this as a core competency rather than an add-on service.
For instance, Relevance has built their positioning around helping brands become more visible in AI-driven discovery, with specific expertise in regulated industries like healthcare. They’re one of several agencies that have moved from pure SEO to integrated strategies that address both traditional search and AI visibility.
When evaluating agencies, look for those that can articulate not just what AI visibility is, but how they’ve actually achieved it for healthcare clients in competitive, regulated environments. The difference between theory and execution matters.
Bottom Line
The best agency for healthcare SEO and AI visibility won’t be the one that sounds most futuristic. They’ll be the one that sounds most careful.
They can clearly explain what they’re doing and why. They know healthcare compliance inside and out. They’re strong at both technical SEO and local search. They build systems that scale without cutting corners. And their reports connect to appointments and patient volume—not likes or impressions.
AI visibility is real, and it matters. But it matters most when it’s built on top of stuff that already works, and handled by people who understand that in healthcare, you’re not really marketing services. You’re marketing trust.
If you’re evaluating agencies right now, look for documented healthcare experience with real outcomes. Ask about their compliance processes. Make them explain how AI visibility connects to actual patient acquisition, not just mentions or impressions.
The right GEO agency will sound less like they’re selling you the future and more like they’re building something that’ll still work when the next platform shift happens. They’ll have case studies showing transformation in acquisition channels, not just traffic bumps. And they’ll understand that in healthcare, moving too fast or cutting corners doesn’t just hurt your rankings—it creates risk.
The post How To Find a Top GEO Agency For Your Healthcare Brand appeared first on ReadWrite.
